Home Page
Cambeltown
Islay
Highlands
Eastern Highlands
Midlands
Speyside
Deveron
Dufftown
Findhorn
Inverness
Livet
Lossie
Rothes
Strathisla
Western Highlands
Northern Highlands
Islands
Lowlands
Other Malts
Whisky Books
Scotland Books
Travel Books
Locate Distilleries
Links
The Balvenie DoubleWood 12-Year-Old
This summer I spent some time revisiting some old friends. It had been a while since I'd tasted The Balvenie DoubleWood, it was a joy to rediscover its smoothly balanced pleasures.

In 1993, when the DoubleWood was introduced, the "finishing" of whisky in wine casks was a relatively new idea. Today, of course, it's a commonplace practice with many (if not most) distilleries offering one or more "finished": releases. The results have been uneven, in some cases disasterous (Auchentoshen Triple Wood comes to mind). The Balvenie DoubleWood is one of the successes, a delicious balance of sweet and dry, soft and spicy flavors.

Lagavulin 16-Year-Old
Looking over the Favorite Malts selections I was surprised to find that I had overlooked Lagavulin -- a major oversight.

Lagavulin isn't a whisky for everyone. The very bigness of flavor and aroma that speaks to the seasoned whisky drinker tends to overpower the novice. My advice to everyone serious about whisky -- buy a bottle of Lagavulin. If you don't care for it now, you will. Put it on the shelf, come back in a year, another year . . . a day will come when it will be a favorite.

The 16-year-old (the only US release) seems to combine all the disparate Islay flavors: it has the smoky, peaty, phenolic flavors of an Ardbeg, the seaweed, salt and iodine of a Laphroaig and Bowmore, and a touch of the smoked-fruit flavor of a Caol Ila. These elements, combined with the softness and gentility of a Bunnahabhain and Bruichladdich, are softened by the balancing contrasts of sherry sweetness and malty dryness.

There are many good whiskies, there are a very few great ones.
The Macallan 15-Year-Old
In 1966 The Macallan gained the distinction of being the first distillery to bottle whisky that was matured exclusively in sherry casks (oloroso casks from Jerez). Other distilleries have "finished" their whiskies with a year or two in sherry casks, and Glendronach has released exclusive sherry cask bottlings, but no one has managed to come close to the consistent quality and character of The Macallan.

The 15-year-old expression, new to the American market, is a delicious example of the sherry cask whisky that The Macallan distillers have made into an art form. From the rich toffee-and-smoke nose, to the dry, smoky finish, it's a unique and exquisite single malt. (This comes from someone who has never been particularly fond of sherry cask whisky!)

If you haven't tasted The Macallan in a while, it's the time to get reacquainted.

Tomatin 12-Year-Old
Frequently, I receive requests for recommendations for affordable single malts. I attempt to balance the Favorite Malts selections with a mixture for all price ranges but I must admit that it's easy to overlook the small gems in favor of a new release from a silent distillery. A visitor recently suggested I pass on a recommendation of Tomatin 12-year-old, noting that it was selling for about $17 a bottle.

Tomatin is a delightful whisky, a step up in flavor from Lowland and lighter Highland malts, without becoming too challenging (like Islay or heavily sherried malts). It exhibits a smooth balance of malty sweetness, a perfumy lightness, a peaty nuttiness, and a smoky softness.

I sometimes surprise guests during an evening of tasting various whiskies. After a sampling of several light malts, Tomatin tastes distinctly rich and flavorful.

Cadenhead Lochside 19-Year-Old
Lochside is a delicious whisky; delicate, fruity, sweet and dry at the same time, with a soft, peaty creaminess. Unfortunately, the distillery was unable in its brief 35 year history to establish a following. Lochside's delicate malt was either buried in blended whiskies or exported to the Spanish market. The fact the distillery was isolated in Montrose rather than in the Speyside, and the misfortune that the facilities were located on prime real estate all led to its demise.

There's currently an opportunity to find out what you've missed. I purchased a bottle of this Cadenhead 19-year-old (1981-2000, 58 vol.), on a trip to Scotland. Finally some bottles have made their way to the US. It's from an oloroso sherry cask, which adds subtle sweet and fruity notes to a relatively dry and faintly peaty malt.

It's delicious, and perhaps your last chance to affordably sample (about $100) a vanishing single malt.

Glenfarclas 12-year-old
Many years ago, at a bar in New Orleans, Louisiana, I came across a bottle of 12-year-old Glenfarclas. I was embarking on a driving tour of Cajun Country and was surprised to find a single malt that wasn't widely distributed in America. In the course of the following week, Glenfarclas and I became good friends.

It may just be the fond memories of a journey through an exotic part of America, but I like to believe that Glenfarclas is a particularly "Nawlins" style of whisky. Perhaps that's why the Sazerac Company of New Orleans was chosen to be the American distributor. It's a whisky that has the sophistication and charm to be at home in an antebellum mansion; comfort and warmth to fortify the soul at a late night voodoo funeral; and the common man earthiness to sip while eating fresh cooked crawfish by the side of the road at a "boiling point".

The nose has an earthy, sweaty, pungent aroma, mixed with sweet vermouth and licorice notes. The palate begins with sherry notes, then a smoky, peaty dryness. The finish is long, dry, smoky, and trails off with echoes of oak.

The Balvenie PortWood 21-year-old
Though it's only the beginning of February, there's a touch of Spring in the air near my home. It's not cold enough for a thick, sherry cask release, yet hasn't warmed up to the point that a light malt is refreshing. There is however, something in between.

The 21-year-old PortWood from The Balvenie has an exquisitely well balanced combination of complex flavors, starting with a grapey sweetness in the nose and continuing through notes of heather, toffee, and anise. A cedary dryness keeps it from becoming overly sweet and heavy, maintaining an appetizing lightness.

Signatory Bladnoch 1974 25-year-old
It wasn't difficult to choose a single malt to usher in what is officially the new millennium. I'll share part of a message I sent to Raymond Armstrong, the owner of Bladnoch distillery, on Christmas Eve:
How nice to hear from you, and with such good news. Bladnoch is operating again!

It must be wonderful to smell the smells, hear the sounds, feel the energy, and most of all -- take pride in the knowledge that you have rescued a piece of living history from extinction. Other than your infectious enthusiasm and the warmth of June and the rest of the staff, there has been a feeling of sadness on my visits to Bladnoch. As though it were haunted by the ghosts of a lively and cherished past. Against all odds you accomplished a seemingly impossible task -- the spirits have returned to Bladnoch. My glass is lifted to you.

As I wrote I sipped a bit of a 25-year-old Signatory bottling of Bladnoch (1974-99, 54.8 vol.). It's a delicious malt that balances the clean, lemony, grassy notes of a young Bladnoch with the cedary, herbal notes that come from 25 years in an oak cask. Few Lowland malts age well beyond their teens as the lightness of the whisky tends to be overpowered by the oak and cedar notes that emerge from the cask. In this case it is a perfect combination of flavors, and a perfect symbol, bridging the Bladnoch of old and the new Bladnoch.

Laphroaig 15-Year-Old
December always finds me in a reflective mood and island or coastal single malts tend to go well with contemplation and introspection. The Laphroaig 15-year-old is a late at night, log fire in the library sort of whisky.

It's a whisky rich with character. A whiff of the nose brings to mind the harshness of storms at sea, of a youth spent drifting and searching for ones place in life. The palate speaks of the strength, confidence, and the sweetness of midlife success and attainment. The finish is a late life reminiscence of paths not taken, opportunities squandered, and ultimately, of comfort and contentment.

Scapa 12-Year-Old
Looking back over past choices it's hard to believe that I haven't selected Scapa as a Favorite Malt. As I've mentioned before, I try to reach a balance between affordable and expensive single malts so that any whisky lover browsing through the selections can find a special malt within their price range.

Scapa is one of those whiskies that falls into the relatively affordable range (about $35 to $45), yet has a following of fans that is almost cult-like in its loyalty and devotion. The distillery has had its ups and downs, and is now managed by Highland Park, the second, and nearby Orkney Island distillery.

Bottled at 40 vol., the color is a full gold. The nose is dry, somewhat dusty, with touches of oak, vanilla, chocolate and anise. The palate is sweet and smooth, with creamy and salty notes. The finish is a little salty, slightly peppery, and leaves with a faint buttery echo. Quit delicious.

Cadenhead Mosstowie 28-Year-Old
While visiting the Cadenhead shop in Campbeltown (below), I came across a plethora of whiskies and vintages I hadn't experienced before. I'll be describing many in the months to come but a special pleasure was finally encountering a Mosstowie.

At one time the Miltonduff distillery had a Lomond still that produced a heavier malt. The still has been demolished but there are still occasional independent bottlings that are released. This Cadenhead 28-year-old (1970-99, 59.6 vol.), is quite exquisite. The color is a full gold, and the nose is rich with cedary, flowery, buttery, creamy notes. The body is slightly thick, syrupy, and continues into a flowery, rosewater and cane sugar sweetness. As the flavor develops, hints of smoke and burnt sugar surface. The finish is soothing, with notes of cream, smoke, polished leather, and subtle floral hints.

A very rich and luxurious expression of a lost single malt that will soon be a distant memory.

Springbank 10-Year-Old
On a recent visit to Campbeltown I spent some time at Springbank Distillery with Sales Executive, Euan Mitchell, and Distillery Manager, Frank McHardy. I mentioned that I was curious about the Springbank that had been maturing in rum casks. Euan poured a sample and I was immediately struck by the rich, butterscotch aroma.

After leaving the distillery I wandered across the street to the Cadenhead shop and purchased a bottle of the new 10-year-old distillery release. There it was! The same distinct buttery, vanilla, creamy, butterscotch flavor. It turns out that the malt has spent a minimum of three years in rum casks. The result is a delicious combination of sweet, rich, candy-like elements, balanced by a lemony, minty crispness

A note: Since writing this review, the distillery has changed the mixture of Springbank malts that go into the 10-year-old. It unfortunately, no longer contains the rum cask whisky.

For the past decade the distillery has tended towards releases that contained a large proportion of sherry cask whisky. It's a very pleasant surprise to encounter a very different Springbank. Paraphrasing Frank McHardy, a large distillery needs to maintain a consistency in its bottlings from year to year and decade to decade. A small, family run distillery like Springbank has the luxury of being able to experiment, and to release the best whisky from its warehouses regardless of whether or not it is consistent with previous releases.

Ben Nevis 10-Year-Old
I decided to feature the Ben Nevis 10-year-old for its uniqueness. I don't think there is another single malt that is similar to Ben Nevis in flavor. Islay malts can be distinctive in their briny, peaty, smokiness. Lowland malts tend to have a distinctive lightness and oftentimes a "toasted marshmallow" quality, and Highland malts tend to be recognized for their fruity, flowery, or sherry characteristics. Ben Nevis stands out from other malts because of its "chocolatey" flavor.

There are hints of chocolate in other malts (The Dalmore and Scapa come to mind), but only in Ben Nevis is chocolate the defining flavor. Along with the chocolate are elements of oranges, tobacco, and a slight creamy, nuttiness. It's really quite delicious and has the depth and appeal of a much older malt.

Ben Nevis is a bit hard to find in the US, and I hadn't sampled it until recently. It has quickly become a favorite.

Littlemill 8-Year-Old
There's a hint of steadfast resistance to change reflected in the packaging of Littlemill. The label and plastic screw cap look as though they haven't been changed since the American company, Barton Brands purchased a share of Littlemill in 1959 and introduced it to the American market. Perhaps that reluctance to adapt to changing times led to the demise of Littlemill -- in 1994 the distillery went into receivership and the stills were shut down.

The good news is that the Loch Lomond company now owns Littlemill and has plans to resume limited production. The bad news is that the current 8-year-old release is from diminishing stores that were produced from stills that were long ago dismantled. The 8-year-old will only be bottled for another two years! There will be older releases (a 17-year-old was recently introduced), but the youthful Littlemill will soon be a fading memory.

Littlemill may be the quintessential lowland malt. The nose carries the distinct, toasted marshmallow, slightly talcum-like aroma. The flavor is at first malty-sweet (not overly so), then gradually fades to a mildly dry finish.

It might be a good idea to put a bottle aside and wait another eight years to see how it compares to the new Littlemill when it is released.

Old Fettercairn 10-Year-Old
Another of the easily overlooked single malts. Sometimes the price of a bottle of whisky can influence the experience of it, even more so the memory of the experience. We want a $300 bottle to be excellent and tend to look for its better qualities. Our expectations are much lower for a $30 bottle, and we tend to look for its failings to determine why it is priced so low.

Old Fettercairn is one of those inexpensive whiskies that I tend to dismiss -- until I sample a bit -- and I'm quickly reminded of what a delicious whisky it is. It has a near perfect balance of rich, nutty, dryness, and a clean, creamy, toffee, sweetness.

Hart Brothers Port Ellen 22-year-old
Unfortunately, it's a single malt that won't be available for much longer. Port Ellen closed in 1983 and though the buildings still stand, the distillery is no longer licensed and there are no plans to resume producing spirit. There are casks of Port Ellen in the hands of independent bottlers but releases are becoming less frequent and at ever increasing prices.

This 22-year-old (1975-97) from Hart Brothers is an excellent example of Port Ellen, and available at a relatively affordable price (about $85.00). The color is a light gold, and the nose is briny, smoky, and medicinal. The palate is sweet and smoky, with an exquisite balance of heathery sweetness, peaty smoke, and seaweedy salt. The finish is dry, smoky, and peppery. Delicious.

The Dalmore 21-year-old
It's a breezy Spring evening. You've finished dinner and wandered out to the porch to collect your thoughts and wind down from a long day. Occasionally there's a shimmering glow from distant lightning, trailed haltingly, by the low rumble of muffled thunder. You stroll back into the house and pour a measure of whisky...

What whisky would you choose? There are many that would be appropriate, but one that immediately comes to mind is The Dalmore 21-year-old. It's a rich expression of a mature, Northern Highland malt -- soft, smooth, well-balanced, with a sherry presence and distinctive notes of oranges and chocolate. Add some hints of smoke, a little oak, a whiff of salt air, and you have a wonderful, complex malt.

Its very complexity begs for introspection, and its balance hints of answers to questions that haven't yet been put into words.

The Glenlivet 12-year-old
After a wet February, and a cold winter of bracing myself with smoky, peaty Islay malts, there's finally a bit of Spring in the air. It's put me in the mood for a lighter Highland single malt. I suppose the local fruit trees in bloom made me think of it, but I suddenly had a craving for the soft, floral nuances of The Glenlivet.

It's a shame The Glenlivet 12-year-old tends be overlooked. I always keep a bottle in the whisky cabinet but it tends to work its way to the back. In the US, The Glenlivet has been an old standby. Long before the recent interest in single malts, most bars had a bottle of the 12-year-old on the shelf. As more and more single malts were introduced to the American market it became interesting to try something new and The Glenlivet began to be forgotten.

It really is an outstanding malt -- clean, flowery, sweet (without becoming cloying). Deceptively simple at first, it eventually opens up a complex array of flavors. If you haven't tasted The Glenlivet 12-year-old in a while, buy a bottle now. It's the perfect drink for a breezy Spring evening.

Comments from a visitor:
Thank you for your recommendation. I have long wondered why we overlook the charms of the Glenlivet 12. In addition to its very " wet " drinkable nature, its nearly unequaled ability to pair with food ( well, not chocolate cake!) it actually embodies the characteristics that captured our interest and continues our quest for the great malts. Good pick my friend.

JH-KC,MO

Arran (No Age Statement)
It's been five years since the Lochranza Distillery first began producing spirit, and Arran whisky has finally arrived on store shelves (at least a few of them, anyway). In an era when many distilleries have been closing it's nice to see a new one appear. Everyone's been waiting to see if Arran whisky will be a success. As evidenced by this youthful release (no age statement, but a 4-year-old), in another few years there will be some very exciting releases.

Released at 43 vol., this release has a pale gold color. The nose is youthful with an abundant cereal grain presence overlaying a floral and sea breeze character. In addition, there's a very pleasant buttery aroma. The palate is quite dry with the same elements in the nose reappearing. The finish is surprisingly complex for a whisky this young, with slight peppery, spicy notes -- and again, that buttery quality.

Talisker 10-year-old
If choosing a single malt to end a century wasn't easy, how do you pick one to start a new millennium? Rather than opt for symbolism, I decided to go back to basics. I wanted a readily available, affordable (this time for most pocketbooks), unique, and most of all -- a great malt.

Talisker isn't for everyone. If you're new to single malts you'll probably hate it, but that doesn't mean it isn't a great whisky. Sooner or later, you'll find yourself on a cold winter's evening by a fire, contemplating the mysteries of life. You'll reach for that bottle of Talisker because it seems to have answers in its fiery independence and refusal to conform. It doesn't ask to be liked, it doesn't care what you think. It has an aloofness that only comes of wisdom and maturity.

Comments from a visitor:
A standing ovation for your millennial malt selection. During a recent snow storm, that showed no sign of letup, I reached for an old friend...my Talisker. Its peppery nature seemed to say 'to hell wi' it, let it snow'. I agreed, and it snowed for two days. Definitely a malt for the millennium (and beyond).

---- JH, Kansas City, MO

Springbank 21-year-old
Choosing a Favorite Malt to end the Twentieth Century has been a difficult decision. How do you cap off a passing century with a toast on New Year's Eve? What whisky would be appropriate? We all have our favorites by flavor, or by circumstance -- they bring back memories of places, people and events.

Many great whiskies of the past came to mind. I thought of Black Bowmore, one of the finest whiskies I've tasted. I thought of toasting with a Port Ellen or another whisky from a distillery that no longer operates or has been destroyed, toasting the losses of the century. I'll probably have a taste of these and several other whiskies, but I wanted to choose a single malt that was readily accessible, affordable (at least not outrageously expensive), and one that signified the best of what is happening in the world of whisky at the end of the century.

For these reasons I chose the Springbank 21-year-old. It is truly a great whisky, combining elements of sherry, oak, seaside salt air, peat, and smoke into an amazingly well-balanced and smooth experience. It's perfect for a cold evening alone by the fire, but not out of place at a party with a group of friends. It comes from a distillery that represents the future of whisky. The Springbank distillery has done much to insure the growth and evolution of single malt whisky. As distilleries are constantly being closed and mothballed, Springbank has managed to grow and even introduce new distillations of Longrow and Hazelburn. In addition, the distillery has introduced a unique program making it possible for Americans to purchase whisky by the cask and have it delivered in partial lots as it matures.

Yes, there'll be a midnight toast to the New Year with a measure of Springbank 21-year-old in my hand.

Cadenhead Highland Park 10-year-old
As a rule I'm not partial to first-fill sherry cask expressions as they most often tend to mask the subtleties of the underlying whisky with a wall of saturated sherry. Sherry cask can be exquisite in a very old whisky, as the other flavors tend to intensify at 25 or 30 years (even 40 or 50) and balance the strength of the sherry.

Currently there is a very notable exception to this rule, an outstanding 10-year-old Highland Park from Cadenhead (1988, 55.1 vol.). While the sherry is still the first impression in both nose and palate, it is not overpowering. A second reading of smoky peat and seaweed and salt quickly sets in, all balanced in a smooth creaminess. Outstanding.

Longrow 10-year-old
Only a few distilleries release several distinctly different malts from the same stills -- periodically a bottling is released from Springbank distillery under the Longrow name. The product quickly disappears from the market and another bottling is released a few years later. 1999 initiated what is expected to be a consistent release of a 10-year-old (in this case two -- a bourbon cask and a sherry cask). Springbank has been distilling Longrow annually for the past 10 years so a steady release can be anticipated.

Both of the 1999 releases are exquisite -- big, smoky, sweet -- seemingly closer to an Islay (Port Ellen, Ardbeg) than a Campbeltown malt. It's a great opportunity to compare these two versions of a legendary single malt but be prepared to pay dearly, about $100 each.

Signatory Ardbeg 8-year-old
A Signatory 8-year-old (1991-99, 43 vol.) is a special treat. I had only encountered older bottlings of Ardbeg that were smooth and rich with smoke, seaweed, peat, oak, and age. Having sampled (and loved) younger Port Ellens and Longrows I was curious about what surprises a young Ardbeg might hold. I was not disappointed.

The 8-year-old is almost clear, with a slight yellow cast. The nose is big and smoky, with notes of pepper, mint, seaweed and iodine -- medicinal. The flavor is sweet, then dry with sourmash notes. A long smoky-peppery-salty finish. There are only 792 bottles of this out there, and going at about $50.00 a bottle. I bought my case.

© 1999-2002 maltwhiskey.com. All rights reserved.